Skip to main content

Politics of Populism Decoded

India has never witnessed any populist movement since independence. The JP movement in 1977 was closest to populism but it was primarily anti-establishment rather than populist. For the first time since independence we are experiencing populist movement. Many has already described this as anarchy and at the same time some are very optimistic. I think this must be analysed and debated as it touches our daily lives.

Emergence of AAP is truly populist movement, a similar version of this which has been experienced by many countries. Populist movement need not to be tilted towards either left or right. History has examples of fascist like Mussolini and revolutionary like Che Guevara. Both represented two extremes. These leaders were very successful in influencing people against ‘System’ and “Elite” to create a place for themselves. They inspired the young generation and convinced them to become activist to garnered political support. The key characteristics of populist leader is that he is able to create an illusion that his integrity can never be compromised, he has courage and passion to fight against the mightiest of the system and his only objective is to fight for people and serve them. There could be many reasons behind rise of populist movement but invariably corruption and complacency of bureaucracy and political parties acts as catalyst to promotion of populism.

Populist movements are essentially based on the premise that a charismatic leader who tries his best to look alike an ordinary citizen always speak for ‘the people’. The rise and fall of movement is highly dependent on public affection for the leader. As long as this affection continues, the charisma of leader flourishes.

Now the question is how populist movement keep the public involved?

Over the period of the time the strategy to galvanize support for populist leader has been shifted to on-line social media. They have developed the ability to collect thousands of supporters within an hour’s time. Sometimes mobilization is crowed is faster than mobilization of forces to control the crowed. In India, ‘Dharna’ has become the important tool to achieve this objective. It is important to notice that when populist government started to slip a bit, even CM resorted to ‘dharna’. Besides this many opportunists also get involve for personal gains.

In Europe the issues are a bit different and they were primarily focused around  anti-immigration or anti- Asian religions etc. However, most of populist movement of 21st century were not that successful. It is to be seen how it progresses in India. Within a very short period of time they have been able to galvanize good enough support to form government and Delhi and have ambition to go national.

Can we equate populist movement with anarchy?

In a way yes. As stated above, the origin of populism lies with the disenchantment of public with the existing ways of working and complete distrust in bureaucracy and its institutions. People always want a quick fix to the problems. Since resolution of problems within the ambit of law is a time consuming process, anarchy becomes the most preferred tool of populist government. By doing so, they constantly keep reminding the people that they are with them. If you notice the actions of AAP government like mid night vigilante, Janta Durbaar, various subsidies and constantly ridiculing the leaders of opposition party and antagonizing the police force, all are part of this strategy.

Most important question is how long is the life of any populist government?

Populist Government is premised on breaking the existing system rather than creating the new system. As long as demolition of institution continues, their supporters feel something different is happening and they keep their support extended. At the same time demolition of institutions causes new set problems. Over the period of time problems caused due to demolition of institutions surpasses the problems created due to ineffectiveness of the existing institutions and this is the time populist government is thrown out. Some people may question why do I think AAP is demolishing the institutions? My simple answer to this is hidden in a counter question. when you paint everyone with the same brush and ask your citizens to do sting operations, what is it if not demolishing. Just think has everyone of us not ridiculed our teachers and professors and regularly indulged in name calling in private. If everyone is worried all the time that someone may be doing a sting, how will he/she will be open and fearless. We live is a society and greed is one of the basic nature of human being. I agree we need to put in additional check and balances so that individuals do not get succumb to the pressure of greed but please do not demolish the institutions.

Life of populist government depends upon the pace with which the existing institutions are demolished. So far AAP has already criticized Judiciary, Bureaucracy, Police, Media and Women commission etc.  I am sure they will continue to follow the same path. I would also like to reiterate that relevance of charismatic populist leader is intact as long as he is able to reassure the people that whatever he is doing is for ‘Public’ not for himself and to protect his image he  will make sure that the myth is not broken. Means more gimmickry and symbolism will continue.

Finally let us all decide how we would like our country to be governed - by Populist movement or Policy driven development framework. Choice is ours.

- RK Bajpai

Popular posts from this blog

Politics of Love and Anger

Politics is ever changing and new thoughts, issues, slogans and narrative are coined regularly. The latest narrative being coined by Rahul ji is about politics of love and anger.
“We shall defeat Modiji’s politics of anger by love”.
First of all, let us understand politics of “anger” and what is the origin. India got independent on 1947 and since then India has been growing with its own pace. There has been all around development but pace of development has been very slow. As a result of this even today 30% people live below poverty line and 80% of the total wealth lies with 10% of population. Forget about education, health, shelter etc India could not even provide toilet to all its countrymen in last 70 years. This is the achievement of last 70 years. Should we get angry at this pace of development? Why India could not increase the speed of development? Probably India believed in politics of “love”. Everyone was dealt with love. No one had any accountability. Everyone was free to tak…

Impact of new Economic Initiatives on Human Development Index

I believe that no rules or laws are good enough to trigger the behavioral changes. Behavioral changes in Indian society of 120 crore people is the most difficult task for any government. The present government tried to influence the behaviour by implementing Clean India mission but still a long way to go. 

Though most of economic initiatives of Indian government were aimed at arresting circulation of black money and improve tax collection but its side effects are much more encouraging. Oppositions parties are shouting on top of their voice to raise concerns about state of economy but are unable to visualize the real changes on the ground.

I can visualize effects of new economic initiatives on the spending behavior of common Indian citizen. All sections of society are impacted my some or other economic policies. The economic policy can be designed for any purpose but results in curbing circulation of black money and when ever circulation of black money is curbed, it will be felt by in…

HAPPY ENDING – Happy ending is integral part of Indian philosophy.

Finally CBI court has given judgement on criminal culpability in 2G case. As expected no one was found guilty and all accused acquitted from all charges. The CBI court took seven years to arrive at this decision. This decision has strengthened peoples believe that our judicial system, investigating agencies and government in power do not have enough will power and teeth to solve corruption cases. It has really shattered India. Irony is that this verdict has come after supreme court has found allocation of 2G spectrum arbitrary and had cancelled all 122 allocations. I am really happy that re-auction of spectrum has fetched more than 1.70 lakh crores therefore all monetary losses have been recovered back.
Let us talk a bit more about corruption.  The corruption has been the key issue during last 30 years or so and people have voted to root out corrupt governments and install a new government. First and foremost major corruption issue was Bofors deal and congress government was dislodged …